Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 

British Columbia -   

Fake Apple iPad 2s made of clay sold in B.C.

Viewer

CTV News Video

Lynda Steele on fake iPads
CTV British Columbia: Lynda Steele on even more fake iPads
CTV British Columbia: Lynda Steele on more fake iPads
CTV British Columbia: Fraud investigation in B.C.

Font-size:     Share  Print  Comments(29)

Photos

Slideshow image

View Larger Image

By: ctvbc.ca

Date: Monday Jan. 16, 2012 4:41 PM PT

Retail giants Future Shop and Best Buy have launched a major fraud investigation involving Apple iPad 2s, after as many as 10 fake models made of modelling clay were sold in Metro Vancouver retail stores.

Future Shop said it appears scam artists bought the popular tablet computers with cash, replaced them with bags of clay and then resealed the boxes and returned them to the store.

The fake tablets were then put back on the shelves and sold to other unsuspecting customers.

"Customers don't expect to receive this kind of product from Future Shop, so it's a very serious matter and something we are addressing right away for anyone who has been impacted," spokesperson Elliott Chun said.

Mark Sandhu thought he bought a $620 iPad 2 for his wife for Christmas, but they received a nasty surprise at the family gift opening on Christmas Eve when they realized there was no computer in the box.

Sandhu said initially his wife Sundeep thought the clay, flattened into the shape of an iPad and housed inside a Ziploc baggie, was actually a protective layer over their new pricey present.

"My wife was excited when she saw this, [saying] ‘oh my God they take care of their stuff,' and then we saw this …and that kind of threw us off a little," Sandhu said, adding that there was also a clay cube where the charger should be in the box.

"I was shocked. I did not expect this from Future Shop. When you purchase something from there you expect the product to be there," he said.

Worried that other consumers were at risk, Sandhu brought the fake product back to the downtown Vancouver location on Boxing Day. But he said he was treated like a criminal by the female manager.

"Maybe the way I was dressed, I don't know," he said. "She made me feel like I'm trying to scam them out of $700. I was the one getting scammed."

Sandhu said he contacted Future Shop head office, Apple and even local police but no one would listen to his story.

It was only after he contacted CTV's Steele on Your Side that Sandhu received a response from the company.

Future Shop said the Surrey man was not the only B.C. consumer who had been ripped off. The company is investigating up to 10 similar cases in Metro Vancouver at Future Shop and Best Buy locations.

Chun would not say which stores the fake devices were sold from. He also would not touch the fake iPad during the CTV interview on the advice of the store lawyer, who warned about leaving fingerprints.

"It really saddens Future Shop to know that people stoop to this type of level to be opportunistic and make money in this sort of organized way," said Chun, who said the company first learned about the fakes in early January.

Sandhu said he's learned a tough lesson, and will never leave a store without opening the package to see what's inside.

"I know better from now on. I don't care what I purchase -- I'm not going back to Future Shop, that's for sure," he said.

Sandhu and his wife have received an apology from the company plus a full refund. They also received a new iPad 2 as compensation for their troubles.

Watch CTV News for a full report from Lynda Steele, and a look at the clay iPad sold to Sandhu. Tune in tomorrow for the second part of our story, including the response from Apple.

Do you know anyone who was sold a fake iPad?  We want to hear from you....

Share with your social Network:

Comments are now closed for this story

Jack Lehner
said
0 0

Why didn't I think of this? lol


Eddy
said
0 0

What is this world coming to..?


BLH
said
0 0

So these 2- retail stores don`t check their products when returned for a refund?!


alpha tolentino
said
0 0

They resealed the wrapping on the outside of the box whats there to check? its like if u take a blow dryer to a xbox 360 void sticker do u know for sure that's not a old xbox 360? nope i bought a 360 once and it had redring of death and later found out that it was returned with old guts inside :) thief's are smart now a days and nothing best buy or fs can do about


Alberta Bound
said
0 0

Maybe it's not clay. Maybe they came up with a new way to ship drugs in an iPad box.


JC
said
0 0

don't buy "open box" returns?


ulfy
said
0 0

I don't believe a fraud consumer artist is at work here,whenever i return something i get the 3rd degree and they check it thoroughly. i'm betting its the kids in Apple's China plants are at work here.


Eric
said
0 0

Futureshop giving a customer the third degree?? No surprise here, their customer service is terrible at best.


poiboy
said
0 0

Clay models still work more effectively that an Android tablet.. bazinga!


John Deere
said
0 0

Future shop rips everybody off all the time. Is anybody really surprised this happened. Total inside job.


pd
said
0 0

that sucks for the people who got scammed, but yea future shop sucks


simone
said
0 0

The depths the criminal element goes to is unbelievable. It takes"buyer beware"to a whole other level. Despicable cretiens


Charlie
said
0 0

I am not surprised the Local police did not listen to, let alone, believe his story.


87Yugo
said
0 0

Its really get bad! What these low lifes will do! But also Its typical how Futureshop treats its customers. I would not spend any money with them anymore! They really need a customer relations course!


Dontshopfutureshop
said
0 0

I have had nothing but terrible experiences dealing with Future Shop. They treat their customers like dirt, accuse you of lying when you try and return a defective item, and then cheat you out of the expensive warranty their peddled to you in the first place. Awful chain store!


Edmund
said
0 0

I don't see why that guy's still pissed at futureshop.Around 2 months of hell, being accused of fraud but in the end you get an apology and a free ipad 2


CSI VANCOUVER
said
0 0

maybe the clay has finger prints in it


Hoppy
said
0 0

Never liked dealing with Future Shop. I never shop there.


MikeJones
said
0 0

Those of you who keep saying "why didn't they check their returns." I hope you understand that these units are being returned SEALED. The con-artists are resealing the iPad's with professional equipment so the product looks brand new. Why would any retail store open up a brand new, sealed product to check it only to make it an open box item? The fraud was out of their control, the refund part was however in their control. Read the story and understand the situation before jumping to conclusions about checking products when they're being returned.


Bob
said
0 0

JC says: don't buy "open box" returns?Why does this comment have ANY thumbs up? Did you guys even read the story? They didn't buy an OPEN BOX product. Open box products are sold at a discount because they're considered "used" and have been opened. These were sold as brand new at full price because the thieves had sealed the box to make it look like it was never open to begin with.


RC
said
0 0

All this negativity about future shop, I've been there several times, the people are more than happy to help you with any problems you have, (actually they go out to their way to help) I've never been there that I couldn't find what I was looking for and the prices are the best in town, Hell I wouldn't have been able to do all my renovations with out.... oh wait, that was Home Depot, Sorry ;( old age sucks and for the record so does future shop! :)


Chris
said
0 0

Fake Apple products were reported from China last summer. Now we have fake Apple products in Canada? Gosh, what is all this?


RL
said
0 0

There's not much to rewrap: the exterior packaging is peel-away clear plastic. Any returns to the stores should be checked and certified and noted as a previously sold item.Personally, if I'm paying full price I expect a factory-new item, not something that has been opened and possibly used.


woody
said
0 0

I hope they were on a good sale . . . like "cheap as dirt . . . or uhh clay "


Kera
said
0 0

FUTURE SHOP SELLS FAKES!!I saw your show about Future Shop selling fake iPads. A few months ago a similar situation happened to my boyfriend. He bought a pair of Monster Beat headphones by Dr. Dre. He had them for about two weeks and one of the head phones stopped working.He had the headphones, the box, packaging, receipt, everything the receipt said he needed to exchange them within a month. He bought them at the Surrey location on 72nd street and when he tried to exchange them 5 different employees, including a manager, looked at the headphones and said they were fakes. They told him that HE had switched them with fakes and was trying to return fakes. He would NEVER do that! He asked the employees to open a new box so they could compare them to the ones he was returning and they refused. He contacted Future Shop’s head office. He had a customer service representative contact him back and said they would send him a new pair; however, that was months ago and he has heard NOTHING since. We figure: someone had purchased the head phones before my boyfriend and returned them with fakes in the box, there is an employee switching items with fakes OR they are poorly trained and the head phones were actually real. We want people to know that Future Shop sells FAKE merchandise! Do not shop there or support Future Shop or Best Buy.


Rev in VC
said
0 0

Any entrepreneurs out there? I smell a market for portable x-ray machines or sonar scanners specially made for electronics retail outlets to check the authenticity of returned product contents.


mammud
said
0 0

This is oldest trick in India and I have bought rock like this almost 42 years before. This time instead of hearing stories of FS//BB scammed me, its FS/BB were scammed.


Rob
said
0 0

What!!!??? I guess they don't check the product on returns nor collect identification or the returnee. Use common sense people.


bezerkr187
said
0 0

open box are checked ,wiped to factory settings and certified then sold cheaper it's actually safer.